Natsumi Tapas – Not Your Typical Murray Hill Spot

May 24, 2016

If you haven’t been able to tell yet, my favorite food is sushi – all types, fish, shapes and sizes. If it was acceptable, I could eat sushi for breakfast, lunch and dinner. When I heard Natsumi was opening a “Tapas” style location on the East Side, I had to pay them a visit ASAP because what’s better than being able to split a bunch of sushi dishes?


I went on a Tuesday night around 6:30PM and it was poppin’ at the bar for Happy Hour. The new modern space, located in “Upper Gramercy” features an Asian-fusion menu with dishes inspired by both Japanese and Italian origins. Interesting, but intriguing right? Who would think to get meatballs or ravioli at an Asian restaurant? Needless to say, I ended up sticking with the Asian route.


The menu was super overwhelming. I probably needed a good half hour to go through the entire thing, but I was so hangry, impulsive and made a quick decision.


Here’s what we got:


TUNA TARTAR MARTINI: avocado, mango, yuzu miso and basil pesto 

This was delicious, but way too tiny, even for tapas…the dish was the size of my fist.


EDAMAME: choice of spicy or sea salt

We got sea salt and it was good. Nothing special.



This was just weird -- definitely not your average seaweed salad. In fact, it's well below average. I would stay away from this.


RAINBOW SASHIMI CUCUMBER ROLL: tuna, salmon, super white tuna and avocado 

Your basic Naruto Roll. It was good and the fish was fresh!


SQUARANO: seared tuna, seared salmon, kani, avocado, scallion, pepperoncini and green tea aioli



This was super interesting. Not a huge pepperoncini fan, but the other fish worked well to mask the taste.


“WOLF HALL” ROLL: spicy salmon, spicy super white tuna, spicy tuna and tobiko over tempura roll

This was my favorite roll by far. I would highly recommend it and wish other restaurants could pull it off. The tri-colored tobiko was also just foodgasmic!


For the time being, I have to give Natsumi Tapas a 7/10. Not sure if I got all the right dishes (except the Wolf Hall roll), but I would like to give it another shot. After all, there are 200 other things on the menu that I haven’t tried. It’s definitely a great spot to go with a big group of friends, so you can sample a bit of everything or a good date spot if you both have the same taste in food. The service was also great and the staff was very nice and attentive. 


Natsumi Tapas

323 3rd ave, E 24th St

Manhattan, NY 10010

(212) 889-2182

Please reload


Please reload

© 2020 | eats and the city